Case Study – Theresa Schiavo (Add (Add (Add Case Study – Theresa Schiavo The plight of Terri (Theresa) Schiavo gives a tragic valuable case study. The conflicts and misunderstandings enveloped within Terri have been well discussed by several personalities in the fields of medicine, law, and ethics. In the midst of media saturation and higher public interest, large amount of confusion hang back about the diagnosis of unrelenting vegetative state of the case, and the judicial process and ethical framework related to Terri’s care. Several issues are associated with the Terri Schiavo case, such as ethical, psychological, medical, religious, legal, and philosophical. Researchers, on the Terri Schiavo case have analyzed what would happen when a patient lacks advance directives, or when one is not able to express one’s own wants due to cognitive loss or being in Persistent Vegetative State (PVS). The lack of legalized documentation, at last brought in an ethical situation. Stopping nourishment for patients who happen to be in a constant vegetative stage is undoubtedly an exposition of ethical dilemma. Issues regarding ethical values directly pose questions about quality of life, standards of living, responsibilities, and choices of the family members. The Terri Schiavo case is associated with a young woman, spending approximately 15 years of her life in a vegetative state. It is also concerned about the conflicts and issues occurred between Terri’s parents and her husband. The central issue of the case was about who must decide her fate. As described in Schiavo Case Resources (2006), in 1990, Terri collapsed from cardiac arrest, stopped breathing and suffered from severe brain damage. She was lying for 15 years, the period which the doctors diagnosed as a vegetative state. She was sustained by a feeding tube, which later became a much argued issue in the court battle between her husband and her parents. She was affected by a heart attack at the age of 27 as a result f electrolyte imbalance secondary to a suspected struggle with bulimia (Schiavo Case Resources, 2006). Terri’s parents wanted to keep the feeding tube for sustaining her life. On the other hand, her husband wanted to get the feeding tube removed. The Schiavo case seems to be very complex with many points to consider. One of them was the argument upon diagnosing the Permanently Vegetative State (PVS) versus a minimal conscious state of the person. Michael Schiavo, her husband argued that Terri was in a permanently vegetative state while her parents argued that she was only in a minimally conscious state. One important ethical question that arises at this situation is when does life end or where. Robert and Mary Schindler seemed more reasonable on their decision than that of Michael Schiavo. They were willing to take up the moral obligation of the issue. They had the right to petition court decision as they were more justifiable than her husband. The ethical element of the issue was looked into by her parents by deciding to preserve the feeding tube. In the beginning, both Michael Schiavo, her spouse, and Terri’s parents were together taking caring of Terri along with the staff at a hospital. But later, Michael Schiavo was appointed legal guardian and surrogate in caring Terri. However, on the ethical perspective, her parents had the moral obligation to continue Terri’s care as her parents. The decision to remove the feeding tube and slowly letting her die cannot be substantiated as the intermittent reflexive smiling and other behavioral changes in Terri had given hope to people who cared for her. The arguments of Michael Schiavo cannot be justified in any case, though his intentions were given attention during the case. He had many conflicts of interest within himself in taking care of Terri which cannot be simply rationalized with any morale concern. In letting Terri’s doctors to take off her feeding tube, he stood to get benefited from a malpractice settlement. He was much inclined to his girlfriend. Such misleading intention of Michael Schiavo sparked the ethical concerns of the community. The case analysis shows that the ethical principles were violated in the case of Theresa (Terri) Schiavo. As Beauchamp and Childress (1994) point out, the principle of Beneficence asks the clinician to promote the interests of the patient, as well as the non-maleficence-duty demand for not to do any harm (p. 259). in the given case, both these ethical principles were seen violated. According to Ashcroft, Dawson, and Draper (2007, p. 5), many fundamental rules in the common morality are the obligation to avoid causing any harm, which include guidelines such as, do not kill, do not cause pain, do not disable, etc. Besides, the principles provide respect for the patient’s autonomy, which keeps up the parent’s health related values. As Jeffrey (2006, p. 35) points out, autonomy can be referred as the ability to think, decide and act on the basis of such thinking and decision, freely and independently. The parents seemed deprived of their right to preserve the life of their daughter. Finally, according to the National Institutes of Health, the justice element of the ethical principle demands to treat the patient fairly according to their medical needs. References Ashcroft, R. E., Dawson, A, Draper, H & McMillan, R. J. (2007). Principles of Health Care Ethics. England: John Wiley and Sons. Beauchamp, T. L & Childress, J. F. (1994). Principles of Biomedical Ethics. UK: Oxford University Press. Jeffrey, D. (2006). Patient-centered Ethics and Communication at the End of Life. UK: Radcliffe Publishing. National Institute of Health: Office of Human Subjects Research. Department of Health Education. (18 April, 1979). “ Regulations and ethical guidelines: Ethical principles and guidelines for the protection of human subjects of research”. Retrieved from http://ohsr. od. nih. gov/guidelines/belmont. html Schiavo case resources: Key events in the case of Theresa Marie Schiavo. (13 October, 2011). University of Miami. Retrieved from http://www6. miami. edu/ethics/schiavo/timeline. htm
Related Essay Samples
Secrecy and openness in the war on terrorism essay example
The presence of security information on the internet and the federal government databases that are accessible to public makes it possible for terrorists to attack without any prior notice by the intelligence service. The presence of government secrecy makes it ...
Report on workplace learning/project
The goods provided at the shopping centers have created a lot of doubt in terms of the quality of the goods. The clients are the population of the shopping centre.
Free capital punishment outline argumentative essay sample
Is this a form of reinforcement and punishment that we want our youth to nurture in?- First Argument Against Capital Punishment:- Capital Punishment is morally wrong - Second Argument Against Capital Punishment:- Capital Punishment is an expensive process - Third ...
Analysis of valet ticket
The purpose of this paper is to explain the strengths and weakness of a valet ticket in terms of its legality. If a car is damaged or a person is injured while is in the hotel, the initial question is ...
My declaration of independence
When in the course of life events, it becomes necessary for me to suspend the mental beliefs which have chained me to false ideals overwhelmed me by others; and when it is necessary for me to assume the strength and ...
The right to privacy
The press plays the role of communication and may in its interest or the interest of the public or groups of followers investigate information about a celebrity and publish the information. Only a reasonable breach of privacy of a celebrity ...
Macbeth and antigone essay
Lady Macbeth calls upon dark spirits hat " tend on mortal thoughts", or spirits that are prone to deadly ideas, to " unsexes" her, literally meaning that she wants to change her gender from a woman to a man and ...
Example of stimulants, depressants, and drugs essay
This is because they may change the effects on the user due to the way in which they may be used and the body type reaction they may cause. Philadelphia: Wolters Kluwer Health/Lippincott Williams & Wilkins, 2009.
the u.s. constitution and the declaration of independence essay sample
Constitution and the Declaration of Independence are two of the oldest documents in America and two of the most popular. You can see the Declaration of Independence announced to the world that the U.S.had become independent and the U.S.
Security proposal research proposals examples
The research has the following objectives;- It seeks to probe insider attacks in multinational corporations by employing industry-wide data - It explores the motivations for insider attacks and whether they are related to employee factors - It explores ways of ...
Example of computer crime-scene investigation term paper
Documentation of the scene is clearly done to ensure that everything that is in the scene can be used as evidence to solve the case. If a crime scene is not well secured possible evidence or devices with evidence can ...
Texas constitution essay sample
Similarly the Constitution of Texas is there to provide the guideline to government regarding how not to impinge upon human rights and individual freedom and simultaneously foster rule of law and respect for human dignity in the state. Some of ...
Online environment and the law
I have read and understand the plagiarism policy as outlined in the syllabus and the sections in the Student Bulletin relating to the IWU Honesty/Cheating Policy. Consumers' awareness of their ability to negotiate over the price and terms of brokerage ...
Example of report on saints and roughnecks article
The general purpose of the study on the Saints and the Roughnecks by William Chambliss was to investigate on the reasons that made the community, school and police have a perception that Saints were respectable, honest and non-delinquent youth with ...
The three e’s of safety essay sample
In this concept, safety is designed into the system and the users will be the ones to cope. Instead of starting with the goal of safety, it starts with the people who are part of the process and whom we ...
Free thesis on sexual harassment in the workplace
All the employees must be aware of legal, social rights in the workplace, and that sexual harassment is a serious illegality that is punishable by the law. The assertion is simply the inculcation of sexual harassment policies that give invaluable ...
U.s v dominique stephens case study sample
The expert witness in battered woman syndrome will corroborate Dominique's evidence and proof that she was suffering from the syndrome at the time when she shot her husband. His evidence will explain the fact that there was abuse in the ...
Example of personal statement on law school
In addition to my extensive education in Criminal Justice, I have worked in the criminal justice system for a number of years, and taught in the higher-education system as a professor and as an academic dean and program director as ...
Silence of the lambs essay sample
After Doctor Lecter spoke to the Senator about her daughter, he was placed in The Cage on the top floor of the courthouse, being part of the deal that he had made with Chilton. Clarice tells me that if I ...
Evaluate the effectiveness essay sample
Evaluate the effectiveness of the domestic and international legal systems in dealing with international crime. There are various domestic and international measures in dealing with international crime as it affects the international community.
Example of the case eric michael clark vs arizona/us term paper
He puts that the expert confirmed to the court that his client was mad hence the crime could not have been conscious. This seemed a difficulty question because the attorney could also see the motive of crime commission in that ...
Nevada constitutions essay sample
Nevada, the " Battle Born" state, became a member of the Union in the midst of the Civil War. Following the capture of the Mexican capital, the Treaty of Hidalgo, signed in February 1848, allowed The United States to gain ...
The legal implications of passing medical law constitutional administrative essay
However despite that, federal government does not have the power to limit the passage of medical marijuana laws by the states and cannot rely on or compel State officials to prosecute a federal crime in opposition to the State law. ...
The essence of the cif contract law contract essay
Under a CIF contract the seller is traditionally deemed[7]to agree a contract of affreightment in order to carry the goods, at the destination[9]at the time specified in the contract or, when the time is not expressly provided, within a reasonable ...
Agreement made by minors are not contracts
The mortgage is not valid, therefore the plaintiff cannot recover the sum advanced to the defendant, because a minor is not competent to contract and hence the minor's contract is void. The third exception that allows a minor to enter ...